The Intelligent Medicine audience comprises both ends of the political spectrum, from Left to Right, and everywhere in between. People of different stripes can find common cause here. The bipartisan nature of this constituency was demonstrated by liberal environmentalist RFK Jr.’s unprecedented partnership with the conservative Trump administration.
Let’s stipulate that, if you follow Intelligent Medicine, regardless of your political persuasion, you’re likely a fan of:
- Freedom of choice in healthcare
- Access to innovative supplements
- Reducing dependency on hi-tech pharmaceutical “fixes”
- Research into safe, effective natural alternatives
- Clean water, air, and food
- Personalized nutrition
- Fitness
- Harnessing lifestyle to improve health outcomes and longevity
- Incentivizing healthy behaviors
- Curbing undue BigPharma influence over health policy
- Preserving access to truthful health information, without censorship
Since when did one party corner the market on all these?
I don’t have all the answers, but here are some thoughts:
Faultlines appear within MAHA
The election brought to a head an internal conflict within the administration. President Trump’s chief of staff—his gatekeeper Susie Wiles—surrendered her job to Steven Miller, a Trump hardliner. What might that mean for the MAHA agenda?
Colleagues of mine with insights into the inner workings of the White House tell me that Wiles has been an impediment to some of MAHA’s most cherished objectives.
On glyphosate rollbacks, for example, the administration whiffed, issuing an emergency order declaring its preservation as a “national defense priority”.
When it came to PFAS—forever chemicals that harm reproductive health and may promote cancer—EPA proposed rescinding regulations and delaying enforcement of standards on certain PFAS compounds.
And, when it came to regulating flavored nicotine vapes that appeal especially to kids, the administration left the door open to sketchy brands.
There’s even a burgeoning scandal around undue influence from the Kratom lobby.
All of these alleged cop outs were blamed on the departing Susie Wiles by Calley Means, the MAHA influencer who recently quit his job as an advisor to RFK Jr. to dish on how industry lobbyists sought to undermine the MAHA agenda.
Means told CBS:
“Underneath Trump’s nose, in many cases, you had a group of former lobbyists, catering to the vaping industry, catering to the ultra-processed food industry, catering to the pharmaceutical industry, catering to the pesticide industry and doing their bidding with an excuse that we need their money for the midterms and really need to actually go against what voters said.”
RFK marked the transition by tweeting: “Next to me, Stephen Miller is the strongest MAHA supporter in the administration. It’s time to unleash the Kraken.”
Kennedy may feel emboldened now that Wiles has been replaced, but he’s likely to be mired in Democratic efforts to investigate him, discredit him with incessant hearings, and even call for his impeachment.
MAHA has a brand problem
The proposition “Make America Healthy Again” sounded pretty uncontroversial, right? That is, until MAHA became associated with MAGA, which just received a drubbing. A recent poll revealed only 29% of Americans now “support MAHA”—whatever that even means.
Unfortunately, I foresee a legislative knee-jerk reaction to MAHA that will cast all of its tenets—regardless whether constructive or not—as part of a MAGA agenda to be repudiated when Democrats regain control of Congress next year. “If Trump and RFK Jr. are fer it, we’re agin’ it!” the new crop of Congressional zealots might argue.
Here’s how that’s likely to shake out:
ENVIRONMENT: Democrats are traditional guardians of the environment, so if they can overcome the impulse to do the opposite of what RFK Jr. is advocating, we might see some strengthening of regulation of harmful pesticides and herbicides, as well as initiatives to curb air and water pollution. Trump’s EPA has been relatively accommodating to the chemical industry, in the name of unleashing “domestic production”, so we might see more efforts to rein in the worst excesses. Both parties, however, have a rather dismal record of rent-seeking from powerful corporate interests.
In the face of skyrocketing energy prices, “Green” initiatives are taking a backseat to “drill-baby-drill”. But with a new Democratic majority there may be efforts to reinvigorate restrictions on fossil fuel production and consumption. Fracking, which has bolstered the U.S.’s efforts at energy self-sufficiency still has real downstream environmental consequences, despite “clean” new technologies. Democrats in my home state of New York have held up fracking around pollution concerns regardless of the economic boon it might have delivered to impoverished upstate regions.
Paradoxically, offshore and land-based wind farms, which conservatives see as a cost-ineffective scourge—harmful to ocean environments and a threat to quality of life of rural communities—might make a comeback under Democratic rule, as well as a revival of Green New Deal strictures on gas-powered cars and appliances.
FOOD: There’s pent-up resentment by orthodox nutrition scientists over RFK Jr.’s green-lighting of red meat and saturated fat. Coupled with pressure from BigFood, Democrats may seek to re-flip the dietary pyramid back to a “plant-based” model. How food choices became so politically polarized defies scientific objectivity—preferences on the dinner plate have come to signify one’s tribal allegiance.
There also may be ramifications for the SNAP program. The Trump administration and Republican governors have made efforts to restrict SNAP access to high-sugar beverages, soda, energy drinks, candy, and prepared desserts. But some Democrats oppose these rollbacks, arguing that they stigmatize the food choices of underserved recipients. The food industry is happy to support continuation of what is, in effect, a lucrative government subsidy—their lobbyists will be eager to plead their case to new receptive Congress members.
RESEARCH: Scientists, medical researchers and university faculty are overwhelmingly Democratic these days. They see the Trump administration’s cutbacks to their research grants as government overreach. Admittedly, there were some missteps during the heydays of DOGE; for example, ideological cost-cutters slashed grants for studies on “trans-mice”, unmindful that this was not about drag queen story hour, but rather standard medical research utilizing transgenic mice.
The research community is jubilant over Democrats’ pledge to reverse grant cutbacks.
But the sad fact remains that only 4% of the multi-billion dollar NIH budget is consecrated to investigation of the impact of diet on disease. There is not even a dedicated division within NIH to study longevity. In our headlong rush to develop pricey “cures”, we have deprioritized natural solutions to our chronic disease epidemic—a stated priority of MAHA that now threatens to lose momentum.
MEDICAL EDUCATION: It’s undeniable that doctors receive insufficient training about diet. Despite an RFK Jr. initiative to compel medical schools and residency programs to offer more nutrition curriculum, many medical schools may just prefer to stall and await the installation of a Congress less supportive of reform. After all, academic medicine’s bread and butter these days is biotech research, which can yield more lucrative returns that underwrite medical education.
SUPPLEMENTS AND NATURAL PRODUCTS: Democrats generally have a track record of being pro-regulatory, ostensibly in the interest of consumer protection. Republicans, on the other hand, have generally favored lowering barriers to access of supplements and innovative therapies. Most recently, the Trump administration demonstrated hospitality to peptides, loosening restrictions to their compounding, triggering derision by skeptics who claim they’re not ready for primetime.
On the other hand, efforts to allow disclosure of truthful information about supplements have stalled.
A Democratic majority Congress is likely to resurrect bills creating onerous drug-like approval pathways for novel supplements, to place dosage limits on existing formulations, or even ban some outright. We’ve seen a preview of such legislation in Democrat-led California and New York, which now restrict access to weight loss and performance supplements by persons under 18—with the consequence that teenagers can no longer buy harmless products like protein powder and creatine.
VACCINE POLICY: In the wake of a partial relaxation of vaccine recommendations by RFK’s HHS, expect a big push to reinstate vaccine requirements from Congress, especially with two newly-elected physicians joining the Democratic Senate majority. They’ve vowed to combat “vaccine misinformation”, bolstered by an uptick in measles cases among the vaccine-hesitant, and will grill RFK Jr. around vaccine policy.
CENSORSHIP? “Newly elected doctors and scientists hope to restore trust in science. It won’t be easy”, headlines STAT News. Hopefully, that will take the form of efforts to improve medical literacy through better communication with consumers—rather than via the deplatforming and shadow-banning of dissenting views that characterized the COVID era. Americans of all stripes have demonstrated that they prefer freedom of choice and informed consent to government diktats.
The challenge ahead
The voters have spoken. Regardless of whether you’re jubilant over the results, or down in the dumps, it would be a shame if Americans’ health were to become collateral damage of November’s apparent rebuke of the Trump agenda.
For more analysis of the election results, see “Who Gets to Decide What Makes Us Healthy?” by the Alliance for Natural Health.



